A control is an action or measure that reduces the likelihood or impact of a risk to an acceptable
level. A control issue is a problem or weakness that affects the effectiveness or efficiency of a
control, such as a gap, deficiency, or failure. A control enhancement is an improvement or
modification that increases the effectiveness or efficiency of a control, such as by adding, replacing,
or updating the control. An external audit is an independent and objective examination of the
enterprise’s activities, processes, or systems, such as the risk management program or thecontrol
environment, by an external party, such as a regulator or a third-party auditor. The best way for a risk
practitioner to verify that management has addressed control issues identified during a previous
external audit is to observe the control enhancements in operation. This will enable the risk
practitioner to evaluate the actual performance and outcome of the control enhancements, and to
determine whether they have resolved or mitigated the control issues. The other options are not the
best way to verify that management has addressed control issues, as they involve different methods
or sources of verification:
Interview control owners means that the risk practitioner asks questions or collects feedback from
the persons or groups who have the authority and accountability to manage the controls and their
issues, such as the business process owners or the IT controls managers. This may provide some
information or evidence on the control enhancements, but it may not be as reliable orobjective as
observing the control enhancements in operation, as the control owners may have biases, conflicts,
or gaps in their knowledge or perception of the control enhancements.
Inspect external audit documentation means that the risk practitioner reviews the reports or records
of the external audit, such as the audit findings, recommendations, or opinions. This may provide
some information or evidence on the control issues, but it may not be as current or relevant as
observing the control enhancements in operation, as the external audit documentation may not
reflect the latest or updated status or results of the control enhancements, or may not cover all the
aspects or components of the control enhancements.
Review management’s detailed action plans means that the risk practitioner examines the
documents that specify the actions to be taken by the management to address the control issues,
such as the resources required, the timelines, the owners, and the expected outcomes. This may
provide some information or evidence on the control enhancements, but it may not be as accurate or
sufficient as observing the control enhancements in operation, as the management’s detailed action
plans may not match the actual implementation or execution of the control enhancements, or may
not account for the uncertainties or complexities of the control enhancements. Reference = Risk and
Information Systems Control Study Manual, 7th Edition, Chapter 2, Section 2.3.3.1, pp. 62-63.