A. $164 million: This result is derived from an incorrect calculation, likely by improperly subtracting the subsidiary's profit and liability movements.
B. $176 million: This figure incorrectly subtracts the gain on the contingent liability or miscalculates the parent's share of post-acquisition profits.
D. $284 million: This figure incorrectly adds the entire post-acquisition profit of the subsidiary ($90m) to the parent's earnings, failing to allocate any share to the non-controlling interest.
References:
1. International Financial Reporting Standard (IFRS) 3, Business Combinations.
Paragraph 23: States that an acquirer must recognize a contingent liability assumed in a business combination at its acquisition-date fair value, even if it is not probable that an outflow of resources will be required. This supports the initial recognition of the $100 million liability.
Paragraph 56: Specifies the subsequent measurement of a contingent liability recognized in a business combination. It requires measurement at the higher of the amount under IAS 37 and the amount initially recognized less cumulative income recognized. Changes in value are typically recognized in profit or loss. The decrease from $100m to $40m results in a gain in the subsidiary's post-acquisition profit.
2. University of Melbourne, Department of Accounting. (2022). ACCT90013 Financial Accounting: Lecture Notes - Consolidation: Intra-group Transactions and Fair Value Adjustments.
Section 4.3, "Fair Value Adjustments at Acquisition Date": The courseware explains that fair value adjustments to a subsidiary's net assets at acquisition date must be accounted for in subsequent periods. The unwinding or remeasurement of these adjustments (such as the gain on the contingent liability) affects the calculation of the subsidiary's post-acquisition profit, which is then allocated between the parent and non-controlling interests.
3. Deloitte. (2021). iGAAP 2021: A guide to IFRS reporting, Volume B.
Chapter 29, Section 3.8.3, "Subsequent measurement of contingent consideration and other contingent payments": This professional guide, interpreting IFRS, clarifies that changes in the fair value of contingent liabilities that are not contingent consideration are recognized in profit or loss in accordance with the relevant IFRS (e.g., IFRS 9 or IAS 37). This confirms that the $60 million gain is a component of post-acquisition profit.