:

:

For each statement in Column 1, we need to determine if it should be explained within the

Commercial Case or the Financial Case based on its content. Here are the answers:

Commercial Case - The use of the open procedure for considering tender responses is typically a part

of procurement strategy, which falls under the Commercial Case. It deals with how the project will be

delivered, the procurement strategy, and the contractual arrangements.

Commercial Case - The potential for opposition from staff when transferring units would also be

considered in the Commercial Case as it relates to stakeholder engagement and the management of

change, both of which are commercial considerations.

Financial Case - An operating surplus from hiring out sports facilities deals directly with financial

performance and sustainability, hence it would be included in the Financial Case.

Neither of the above - This statement about student satisfaction and attendance rates is more

related to the outcomes and benefits, which would typically be covered in the Economic Case or

Benefits Realization Plan rather than the Commercial or Financial Cases.

Financial Case - The net overall saving in the cost of contracts for cleaning is a financial consideration,

dealing with cost savings and expenditure, and therefore should be included in the Financial Case.

Financial Case - Structuring payments to incentivize delivery would be part of the payment

mechanism and financial structuring, which are addressed in the Financial Case.

Therefore, the answers from Column 2 would be:

A

A

B

C

B

B

Based on the provided scenario and information, here's the matching between Column 1 and

Column 2 for the Outline Business Case (OBC):

The Old Fire Station Headquarters site was valued to be sold at $450,000, but will now be used for

the new campus. It is owned by the Council so there is no cost to the project.

B. Economic Appraisal

The attainment of qualifications must increase by 15% through the provision of better facilities.

A. Critical success factors

The Value For Money assessment has identified that it is 12% cheaper to use a privately financed

solution for the Pittville University project, rather than a conventional procurement.

B. Economic Appraisal

There may be substantial opposition from staff and parents to transferring all further education units

to the New Learning Campus. This could affect approval of the project and uptake of the courses

offered.

E. Risk assessment

The minimum action that could be adopted is to introduce a learning network. This would use

existing schools and universities, to provide 55 education course choices at the current level of

participation.

C. Short-listed options

: